Coping Mechanisms for the Blind

Coping Mechanisms for the Blind

Student’s Name

Institutional Affiliation

Abstract

            The loss of vision has significant impacts on the lives of the individuals, families, acquaintances, and the society at large. This paper focuses on a population segment consisting of adults who have been confirmed legally blind for less than one year with the condition and enrolled at the Bureau of Services for Blind Persons (BSBP). It aims to reduce the symptoms of depression, anxiety, and social isolation for adults recently diagnosed with legal blindness in the past one year. Adults who lost their eyesight less than a year ago are highly likely to be depressed due to the effects of visual impairment on their careers, social support systems, and mobility. With the increasing number of the visual impaired population in the U.S., there is a need for a theoretical and institutional response to reduce the negative effects caused by depression. More focus is needed for young adults who are in a transitional stage where the majority are concentrating on join post-high school institution, getting the first dream job, and starting serious relationship as well as the elderly who have lost the social ties duet to age and visual impairment.

Coping Mechanisms for the Visually Impaired

The loss of vision has significant impacts on the lives of the individuals, families, acquaintances, and the society at large. According to Welp, Woodbury, McCoy, Teutsch & National Academies (2016), adults who completely lose their eyesight get frightened and overwhelmed. They are left to wonder about their ability to remain independent, cater for the needed medical costs, keep their places at work, and fend for themselves as well as their families. The health consequences coming with the untimely loss of eyesight is beyond eye and visual system. It affects the quality of life, leading to other effects such as injuries due to falls, mental problems, and general deterioration in social and economic aspects.  In the United States, there are organizations which help the blind to cope. This paper focuses on a population segment consisting of adults who have been confirmed legally blind for less than one year with the condition and enrolled at the Bureau of Services for Blind Persons (BSBP). The group recognizes that adults undergo depression, anxiety, and social isolation. Therefore, this group takes the initiative to design mechanisms to assist the newly blind adults to cope in the society.

Statement of Purpose

According to the latest statistics by the World Health Organization (2018), it is estimated that about 1.3 billion people are a given form of vision impairment. In this category, WHO (2018) says that 80% of vision loss can be avoided. Loss of eyesight is majorly caused by the failure to correct refractive errors, cataract, diabetic retinopathy, and corneal opacity (WHO, 2018). The effects of the loss are traumatizing for individuals who had not experience until in adulthood. The become stressed due to the realities of losing their positions at the workplace to take care of themselves and families, loss the social connection and must now depend on others or visuals aids for movement. According to Coker et al. (2018), the number of cases of losing eyesight is expected to increase by 2050. Varma et al. (2016) state that the 1.02 million figure in 2015 is expected to reach 2.0 million by 2050. As such, the need for centers where individuals who have lost their vision can be rehabilitated is necessary for response to the side effects of baring the loss of vision. It is against this backdrop that our group, in collaboration with the Bureau of Services for Blind Persons, purpose to conduct a group therapy for the visually impaired adults. The therapy aims to reduce the symptoms of depression, anxiety, and social isolation for adults recently diagnosed with legal blindness in the past one year.

Theoretical Orientation

The study will be based on the theoretical postulations of Erik Erikson (Erikson, Paul, Heider, & Gardner, 1959). According to Erikson’s theory of psychosocial development, humans go through eight states of personality growth (Erikson, Paul, Heider, & Gardner, 1959). The process of development through the stages of life is marked by various challenges that are can be upheld to assist in the future or cause difficulties. Though Erikson believed that the stages build on the preceding ones, one does not need to master the previous stage to move to the next. In the current study, the onset of visual impairment on the developmental life of adults presents varying levels of psychological effects. Erikson’s theory will help in understanding the depressive implications in relation to the variables of social support, career, and mobility.

Setting

The Bureau of Services for Blind Persons (BSBP). BSBP holds that the individuals who have lost their eyesight possess the capacity to achieve employment and independence. The organization trains the blind and offer other empowering services that assist the visually impaired to realize their personal goals.

Target Population

Our groups selected adults who are between 18 and 65 years who lost their vision within the last year. The individuals were already enrolled at BSBP. Lastly, the segment selected have their depressive level at a Becks Inventory score of 21. The target group is greatly affected in key areas such as mobility, careers and social support. However, given the wide range of age variation in this study, it is imperative to consider the importance of the age demographic at various stages.

How Adult Visual Impairment Influence Depression

Aspects of Social Support, Career, and Mobility

Permanent loss of eyesight is a traumatizing experience to adults. The change upsets the psychosocial condition of the adult as well as the economic goals in terms of career. According to Choi, Lee, & Lee (2018), visual impairment increases the risk of depression, which varies with age and socio-economic status. Using a sample of 1, 025, 340 participants in Korea, with a longitudinal design, the three researchers studied the level of depression in the visually impaired and compared it with the depression level of the control group. The study was conducted from 2002 to 2013. In another study based in the U.S., Chou, Beckles, Zhang, & Saaddine (2015) explored how the socio-economic status was associated with sensory impairment to explore the depressive effect of the loss of vision. There was no association between economic status and visual impairment. Using content analysis to link the two variable, the researcher indicated that economic stability reduced the stress due to visual impairment.

The discourse of visual impairment has been dominated by the need for care for the older population (Garcia, 2017). Research has also concentrated on the elderly, yet young adults are worth a significant share of attention. According to Elsman, van Rens, & van Nispen (2017), over 200 million people are affected by visual impairment.  Although majority of the visual disability goes to the elderly, over 80 million are between 14 and 49 years (Elsman, van Rens, & van Nispen, 2017). At all the stages, visual impairment comes with a myriad of challenges both socially, economically, and psychologically.

Elsman, van Rens, & van Nispen (2017) studied young adults between 18 and 25 years to explore the aspect of their lives affected by the loss of eyesight. A sample of 22 visually impaired adults and 16 rehabilitation professionals were enrolled for the study. The participants were involved in an online concept mapping workshop based on the objectives of the study. The resulting concepts after multidimensional scaling summed up 11 clusters. Young adults were found to be affected in their social life, work, mobility, and independence (Elsman, van Rens, & van Nispen, 2017). The current study concentrates on mobility, work, and social aspect.

Young adults are in a transitional stage where the majority are concentrating on join post-high school institution, getting the first dream job, and starting serious relationships. The stage itself is stressing because of the inexperience of managing these important life aspects Cherry (2014). For our study population, it is a double tragedy. Imagine a normal high school graduate who is has received an invitation to join the prestigious Harvard, or the ambitious young lady who received secured her first recruitment letter. The two are diagnosed with legal blindness months after achieving such important milestones. The feeling can never be clearer: it I stressful and humbling, and the outcome is a great depression. Elsman, van Rens, & van Nispen (2017) notes that regrets that the stage is accompanied by serious challenges and regrets that the complications are more pronounced for those entering the period with disabilities.

Socially, the loss of eyesight presents the risk of reduced participation and social exclusion. Garcia et al. (2017) argue that visual impairment has significant negative psychological and psychosocial effects in young, middle-aged and older adults. For young adults, it brings the problem of initiating and sustaining romantic relations. In the worst case scenario, young adults with visual impairment may be shunned by their peers. Living with the reality that one can longer make as many friends and that the few are not interested after learning of the eyesight loss. Garcia et al. (2017) studied the effects of visual impairment on the psychological well-being of young and middle-aged adults. The study looked at the mood, career and interpersonal interactions. Results showed that 49.5% of the 103 participants met the depression criteria after losing their vision. The researchers also found that participants showed negative interpersonal interaction and work goals.  

Career

The depressive levels due to visual impairment vary with age. According to Elsman, van Rens, & van Nispen (2017), young adults are a special group in terms of psychological adaptation to the problems brought by the loss of vision. Young adults consider education important for future socioeconomic status as they are normative social roles to the young adults. When they lose their eyesight, the dreams of furthering their studies to achieve career dreams fade and youths become stressed.  Older adults are the least affected in career aspects according to the Erikson’s psychosocial development theory because they worked to achieve their career goals (Cherry, 2014). Garcia (2017) found that younger adults were affected by psychological adaptation and coping while the elderly have difficulties in handling social exclusion since they have reduced social network size. On the other hand, middle-aged adults are adversely affected by the disruption in their career. At mid-age, adults have spent a good fortune in establishing a career (Welp et al., 2016). They are keen to keep their positive work trajectory to help in fulfilling life ambitions and responsibilities. The loss of vision throws everything in disarray. Mid-aged adults get depressed because of the fear of losing workplace positions and career network, leading to dependency.

Mobility

Gleeson, Sherrington, Borkowski, & Keay (2014) posit that posture relies on eye vision. Loss of visual impairment increase the risk of falls with the increase in age (Gleeson, Sherrington, Borkowski, & Keay, 2014). According to Welp et al. (2016), the individuals (adults) who have lost their eyesight recently were enjoying the primary sense that helped in three-dimensional movement. Loss of vision makes the adults highly vulnerable to falls and subsequent injury. The relationship between vision loss and mobility problems are documented in research. Welp et al. (2016), found that 46.7% of individuals with serious vision problems were found to have fallen within during the past year. The participants for the study were obtained from the 2014 BRFSS data. The aim of the study was to determine how prevalent adults who are 65 years or older are to falls or injuries as caused by falls. The results were compared to the fall rate in adults of the same age but with no visual impairment. Only 27.7% fell in the past year.

Crews (2016) asserts that adults who have lost their visions are at high risk of falling. Falling is influenced by factors such as the sensitivity of contrast and lost balance and poor visual acuity. The adults also become week in their lower muscles, develop other chronic complications and use numerous drugs. The risk factors increase the chances of fall for the visually impaired (Crews, 2016). Wahl (2016) looked at the problem of mobility using the perspective of the physical-spatial environment. The researcher argued that in order to understand the mobility problem for the individuals who have lost their vision, it is important to look at the person-environment fit models. Wahl (2013) points out that the person-environment models have the assumption that environmental problems such as poor lighting or floor conditions are likely to reveal a certain strong negative impact when competence is low. This implies that loss of vision interferes with a person’s vision competency, leading to locomotion inabilities in troubled environments.  

In middle-age, the depression that comes with the loss of eyesight is less compared to adulthood (Elsman, van Rens, & van Nispen, 2017). However, the effects are still devastating for a stage of human development characterized by high career ambitions. Chandrasekaran et al. (2017) conducted a longitudinal study consisting of 483 women in Michigan. They wanted to assess how the loss of eyesight influenced the future functioning in mid-age. The participants’ ages ranged between 42 and 56 years. After following the physical functioning of the participants for up to 10 years, it was found that visual impairment has a negative effect on the physical functionality of middle-aged women. The effects are linked to mental effects of poor physical functioning. If a middle-aged woman learns that the recent blind status have future physical implications, they are likely to be stressed. As Chandrasekaran et al. (2017) opine, the level of mood defects in mid-age adults are higher compared to older adults. This implies that adults whose visual impairment are likely to cause future physical function are more likely to be depressed. Therefore, the adults with new onset of blindness need support to help in the attenuation of the current and predicted effects on their physical functioning.

Social Support

Human beings are social, often using the environment for positive social interaction. Vision, like other sensory aspects, plays a significant role to that effect. The onset of visual impairment in adulthood upsets the existing social structures established by the adults. According to Wahl (2013), the social environment influences the mental condition of adults. The research uses the socio-emotional selectivity theory to explain the psychosocial effects of visual loss among older adults. The theory argues that older adults use a good proportion of their time to maintain close and intimate relationships due to the limited time coming with old age. With a lost vision, depression levels are likely to increase as it is added to the inability to make new social ties. The adult gets more depressed when the psychological insecurity sets in that they can no longer participate fully in maintaining the intimate relationship.

The studies used in the literature discussion have limitations in proposing ways to reduce the depressive effects of visual impairment. The purpose of the current study is to design group therapies for adults recently found blind. Tolman, Hill, Kleinschmidt, & Gregg (2005) conducted a study to examine the psychosocial adaptation for losing eyesight in relation to the depressive symptoms. 144 legally blind participants had their levels of depression observed using psychological screening tools. It was found that adults developed adaptive factors such as accepting the loss of vision, negative effects of relationships, and attitudinal response to compensation.

The therapeutic strategies for this group aim to mitigate the depressive effects of visual impairment in relation to the social support, career, and mobility of the patient. The study hypothesizes that supportive therapies will help legally blind adults accept the conditions to reduce depression. The study can form the foundation for future research where more investigation is done on a larger age segment. Based on the theoretical foundation, understanding the relationship between a recent visual impairment across all ages helps in formulating therapeutic strategies that are proactive.

Recruitment: Needs Assessment, Pre-screening Methods

The participants will be drawn from the BSBP program. The existence of the participants at the facility will help us to conduct a purposive sampling as most of the criteria were used when the facility enrolled the visually impaired for their services. However, our therapy will involve adults whose condition has lasted only one year. The group will consult trained instructors on matters of sensory sensibility to screen the participants for legal blind condition and the one-year taken since onset.

Additionally, the demographic data about the participants will be collected at the day of selection before screening and assessment. The study will be specific aspects such as mobility, social relationship, and career goals. The inclusion criteria will be as follows: visual impairment (status <1 year); depressive level (Becks Inventory score of 21), and age (18-65 years).  Being that the kind of study will take time, a longitudinal method will be used. The sessions will be organized after consultation with the management at BSBP to ensure there are no time-table clashes.

Leadership Skills

            The research group offers leadership opportunity skill for the upcoming psychologist. Although the group will work collectively, the position of a leader is inevitable. The first skills is effective communication. The leader has to communicate in a clear, open, and accountable manner. The skills have to be adjusted by multicultural skills due to group diversity as well as the society which is a significant component of research. Secondly, the leader should have administrative skills. Skills such as effective planning, delegation of duties, managing conflicts, and empowering members are vital administrative skill-cum-roles helpful for leadership. Thirdly, should have the ability to work under pressure to manage the levels of anxiety that is implicit in the course of research work. Lastly, the leader should be knowledgeable of the activities and the team members during the research process. The leader is the reference point for everything, contentious or not. Bundy (2017) argues that the team leader can stay knowledgeable by engaging the team with technical questions and appreciating the capabilities of every member.

Limitations

            This study will be carried out among a population who are likely to be traumatized, making it hard to administer the interventions. However, the researchers will be prepared to take their time to establish a cordial relationship with the participants The process of data collection will be tiresome due to the trauma among the participants. Researchers will solve the issue by getting the consent of the families of the close social ties to the participant by explaining the benefits of the program.

References

Bundy, M. L. (2017). Good practice and recommendations for research team leadership (No. ARL-SR-0372). U.S. Army Research Laboratory Aberdeen Proving Ground United States.

Chandrasekaran, N., Harlow, S., Moroi, S., Musch, D., Peng, Q., & Karvonen-Gutierrez, C. (2017). Visual impairment at baseline is associated with future poor physical functioning among middle-aged women: The Study of Women’s Health across the Nation, Michigan Site. Maturitas, 96, 33-38.

Cherry, K. (2014). Erikson’s Eight Stages of Psychosocial Development. Explore Psychology. Retrieved from https://www.explorepsychology.com/psychosocial-development/

Choi, H. G., Lee, M. J., & Lee, S. M. (2018). Visual impairment and risk of depression: A longitudinal follow-up study using a national sample cohort. Scientific reports, 8(1), 2083.

Chou, C. F., Beckles, G. L., Zhang, X., & Saaddine, J. B. (2015). Association of socioeconomic position with sensory impairment among US working-aged adults. American Journal of Public Health, 105(6), 1262-1268.

Coker, M. A., Huisingh, C. E., McGwin, G., Read, R. W., Swanson, M. W., Dreer, L. E., ... & Owsley, C. (2018). Rehabilitation referral for patients with irreversible vision impairment seen in a public safety-net eye clinic. JAMA Ophthalmology, 136(4), 400-408.

Crews, J. E. (2016). Falls among persons aged≥ 65 years with and without severe vision impairment—United States, 2014. MMWR. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 65.

Elsman, E. B. M., van Rens, G. H. M. B., & van Nispen, R. M. A. (2017). Impact of visual impairment on the lives of young adults in the Netherlands: a concept-mapping approach. Disability and Rehabilitation, 39(26), 2607-2618.

Erikson, E. H., Paul, I. H., Heider, F., & Gardner, R. W. (1959). Psychological issues (Vol. 1). International Universities Press.

Garcia, G. A., Khoshnevis, M., Gale, J., Frousiakis, S. E., Hwang, T. J., Poincenot, L., & Sadun, A. A. (2017). Profound vision loss impairs psychological well-being in young and middle-aged individuals. Clinical Ophthalmology (Auckland, NZ), 11, 417.

Gleeson, M., Sherrington, C., Borkowski, E., & Keay, L. (2014). Improving balance and mobility in people over 50 years of age with vision impairments: can the Alexander Technique help? A study protocol for the VISIBILITY randomized controlled trial. Injury Prevention, 20(1), e3-e3.

Tolman, J., Hill, R. D., Kleinschmidt, J. J., & Gregg, C. H. (2005). Psychosocial adaptation to visual impairment and its relationship to depressive affect in older adults with age-related macular degeneration. The Gerontologist, 45(6), 747-753.

Varma, R., Vajaranant, T. S., Burkemper, B., Wu, S., Torres, M., Hsu, C., & McKean-Cowdin, R. (2016). Visual impairment and blindness in adults in the United States: demographic and geographic variations from 2015 to 2050. JAMA Ophthalmology, 134(7), 802-809.

Welp, A., Woodbury, R. B., McCoy, M. A., Teutsch, S. M., & National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. (2016). Eye and vision care professionals and education. In Making Eye Health a Population Health Imperative: Vision for Tomorrow. National Academies Press (US).

WHO (2018). Blindness and vision impairment. http://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/blindness-and-visual-impairment/